Welcome to the new School of Podcasting!
Nov. 20, 2026

Why Most Podcasts Fail (And How Yours Won't)

Why Most Podcasts Fail (And How Yours Won't)

Seven Reasons Why Podcasts Fail

I've been around podcasting long enough to watch a lot of shows come and go. Some of them were good. Some of them were really good. And most of them are now sitting in a podcast app somewhere with a last episode date of "a long time ago." We call that podfading, and it happens to way more shows than make it.

Here's the thing: most podcasts don't fail because the host was bad at podcasting. They fail for a handful of very predictable reasons. The good news? Every one of them is fixable.

1. They Don't Know Why They're Doing It

If you don't know where you're going, any road will get you there. I ask every new client the same question: "Why are you podcasting?" and you'd be amazed how many people say, "Well... everyone said I should have a podcast."

That's not a goal. That's peer pressure.

Your show needs a job. Maybe it builds your authority, maybe it drives people to your membership, maybe it's a hobby that makes you happy (that's a perfectly good reason). But when you know the why, you know what success looks like, and you know when you're winning.

2. They Expect 10,000 Downloads Overnight

Everyone is looking for the switch. The one trick that flips on a huge audience by Tuesday. I hate to be the bearer of bad news, but that switch doesn't exist.

It's like a golfer who swings as hard as humanly possible. It almost always goes sideways. The pros aren't out-muscling everyone. They're making solid, repeatable contact. Podcasting works the same way. When reality doesn't match the fantasy around episode 8, a lot of people quit. Don't be one of them.

3. They Talk to Everyone (Which Means No One)

"My podcast is for anyone who likes good conversation." Okay. So it's for nobody.

It's not about getting a large audience. It's about getting the right audience. Five hundred people who trust you and take action will do more for you than 50,000 people who scroll past. Downloads don't buy your product. Connected people do.

4. Their Content Is... Fine

Not bad. Just average. And average doesn't get shared.

Turning on two microphones and shooting the shinola with your buddy probably isn't amazing content. And with AI cranking out a mountain of sound-alike content, "fine" is even easier to ignore. You need to be relevant and you need to resonate. Learn to tell a story. Figure out where the story actually starts (hint: it's usually later than you think), and cut the stuff the listener doesn't need.

Remember, an episode is content and delivery. Great info delivered in a boring way won't work. Great delivery about paint drying won't work either.

5. They Think "Build It and They Will Come" Is a Strategy

That's a Kevin Costner movie, not a marketing plan.

You have to go where your audience already is and tell them about your show. Be a guest on other podcasts. Do a promo swap. Speak at events. Write for the publications your audience already reads. Ask your current listeners to tell one friend. You don't need to do all of it. You need to find the two or three rooms where your people already hang out, and show up there consistently.

6. They Burn Out

Podcasting takes time. If you're editing until 2 a.m. every week, eventually life is going to win. Build a system. Batch record. Keep a list of episode ideas so you never stare at a blank page. And if you need a break, plan one. Tell your audience you'll be back on a specific date. A planned break is a vacation. An unplanned one is the beginning of a podfade. I always recommend that you time everything and pick your schedule later.

7. They Measure the Wrong Thing

We've gotten really good at measuring attention and forgotten how to measure connection. Downloads are nice, but did anyone join your email list? Reply to your newsletter? Sign up for your membership? Leave you a voicemail?

Put a trackable link on your show notes, your social bios, your business card (I timed it, it takes 42 seconds - Check out Switchy). Then look past the click and see what actually turned into a relationship. Keep what's working. Quietly let go of what isn't. No guilt required.

Podcasts Don't Fail. Podcasters Quit.

That's really what it comes down to. The shows that make it aren't always the most talented. They're the ones with a clear reason, a specific audience, content worth sharing, and a host who kept showing up long enough for it to work.

If you want help with any of this, that's what we do at the School of Podcasting. You get courses, an amazing community, and coaching with me. Head to schoolofpodcasting.com and use the coupon code LISTENER for a monthly, quarterly, or yearly membership.

Now go make something people would miss if it were gone.

Leave a Message